Sermon 8: The First-Fruits of the Spirit

233

An Introductory Comment

Wesley’s accent on salvation by faith as salvation from sin had already raised the question of ‘sin in believers’ and had involved him in the tortured debates about the residues of sin in the believer (fomes peccati) after justification and reconciliation. The classical Protestant doctrine of invincible concupiscence had supported Luther’s characterization of the Christian as simul justus et peccator (see No. 13, On Sin in Believers). But this collided with Wesley’s holy living tradition, and it deferred entire sanctification until in statu gloriae (‘in the state of glory only’). It also fed the flames of scrupulosity, so that one of the marks of Puritan examinations of conscience had come to be self-accusation and self-reproach.

In this sermon (one of only five recorded uses of Rom. 8:1; another in 1741, two in 1745, and one in 1760) Wesley is wrestling with the problem of Christian self-accusation. It is a problem for those who already profess faith in Christ but who retain their guilty memories and are still aware of continued shortfallings.

Here, then, is an early statement of Wesley’s ‘third alternative’ to two extremes: of Christians, on the one hand, who might continue in sin and still plead Christ’s atoning mercies, and Christians, on the other, who sag toward despair under the weight of their guilt-ridden consciences. The crucial distinction is between wilful sins—lapses for which guilt and repentance are the sinner’s only hope—and the residue of sin in believers for which ‘there is therefore now no condemnation in Christ Jesus’. It is this sort of surcease from guilt and anxiety that Wesley here identifies as ‘the first-fruits of the Spirit’. This, then, is a preparatory essay on the paradox of a Christian’s sensitivity (in repentance) and serenity (in grace). Thus it belongs with Christian Perfection and its qualifiers (Wandering Thoughts, On Sin in Believers, and The Repentance of Believers) as part of Wesley’s composite doctrine of salvation as pardon and of its fruits as a deliverance of the Christian conscience from anxiety and guilt.

Yet another angle of the same, ancient controversy may be seen in Wesley’s rejection of the Calvinist contention for ‘the perseverance of the 234saints’. For Wesley, the way from the threshold to the plerophory of faith is a risky one, chiefly because the residues of sin are forever capable of thrusting themselves up to the level of direct temptation or even something like unconscious control. Christians walk in the certainties of grace with the assurance that sins repented are always forgivable, but they must always be alert lest the ‘remains of sin’ turn into wilful sins (which, unrepented, lead to backsliding). Here then, is an early sample of Wesley’s lifelong endeavour to hold both ‘faith alone’ and ‘holy living’ in the same integrated vision of Christian existence.

The First-fruits of the Spirit

Romans 8:1

There is therefore now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.

11. By ‘them which are in Christ Jesus’ St. Paul evidently means those who truly believe in him; those who ‘being justified by faith, have peace with God, through our Lord Jesus Christ’.

1

Rom. 5:1.

They who thus believe do no longer ‘walk after the flesh’, no longer follow the motions of corrupt nature, but ‘after the Spirit’. Both their thoughts, words, and works are under the direction of the blessed Spirit of God.

22. ‘There is therefore now no condemnation to’ these. There is no condemnation to them from God, for he hath ‘justified them freely by his grace, through the redemption that is in Jesus’.

2

Cf. Rom. 3:24.

He hath forgiven all their iniquities, and blotted out all their sins. And there is no condemnation to them from within, for they ‘have received, not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit which is of God, that they might know the things which are freely given to them of God’:

1 Cor. 2:12.

‘which Spirit beareth witness with their spirits that they are the children of God’.

3

Cf. Rom. 8:16.

And to this is added ‘the testimony 235of their conscience, that in simplicity and godly sincerity, not with fleshly wisdom, but by the grace of God, they have had their conversation in the world’.

2 Cor. 1:12.

33. But because this Scripture has been so frequently misunderstood, and that in so dangerous a manner; because such multitudes of ‘unlearned and unstable men’ (οἱ ἀμαθεῖς καὶ ἀστήρικτοι,

4

Cf. 2 Pet. 3:16.

men untaught of God, and consequently unestablished in ‘the truth which is after godliness’)

5

Titus 1:1.

have ‘wrested it to their own destruction’;

6

Cf. 2 Pet. 3:16.

I propose to show as clearly as I can, first, who those are ‘which are in Christ Jesus, and walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit’; and secondly, how ‘there is no condemnation to’ these.

7

Cf. Rom. 8:1.

I shall conclude with some practical inferences.

1

1I. 1. First, I am to show who those are that ‘are in Christ Jesus’. And are they not those who believe in his name? Those who are ‘found in him, not having their own righteousness, but the righteousness which is of God by faith’?

8

Cf. Phil. 3:9.

These, who ‘have redemption through his blood’,

9

Eph. 1:7; Col. 1:14.

are properly said to be ‘in him’, for they ‘dwell in Christ and Christ in them’.

10

Cf.1 John 4:13.

They are ‘joined unto the Lord in one Spirit’.

11

1 Cor. 6:17.

They are engrafted into him as branches into the vine.

12

See John 15:4-5.

They are united, as members to their head, in a manner which words cannot express, nor could it before enter into their hearts to conceive.

13

See 1 Cor. 12:12-27; John 15:1-8.

22. Now ‘whosoever abideth in him sinneth not,’

14

1 John 3:6.

‘walketh not after the flesh’. The flesh, in the usual language of St. Paul, signifies corrupt nature. In this sense he uses the word, writing to the Galatians, ‘The works of the flesh are manifest;’

Gal. 5:19.

and a little before, ‘Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfil the lust (or desire) of the flesh.’

Ver. 16.

To prove which, namely, that those who ‘walk by the Spirit do not fulfil the lust of the flesh’, he immediately adds, ‘For the flesh lusteth against the spirit; but the spirit lusteth against the flesh (for these are contrary to each other), that ye may not do the things which ye would.’ So the 236words are literally translated (ἵνα μὴ ἅ ἅν θέλετε, ταῦτα ποιῆτε);

15

Cf. Gal. 5:17, as in TR: Wesley’s printers introduced a medley of variant breathings and accents (e.g., Pine [1771] ἴνα μὴ ἅ ἁν θέλητε). Modern critical edns. read ἐὰν instead of the contraction, ἄν, and most modern translators take the whole phrase as a negative subjunctive, meaning ‘so that what you will to do you cannot do’ (NEB); cf. Goodspeed, Knox, etc. Wesley will not have it so: our moral disabilities are not part of God’s original design for mankind; always, a remnant of freedom (and, therefore, of responsibility) remains. Cf. Nos. 13, On Sin in Believers, I.3, IV.7; and 43, The Scripture Way of Salvation, III.6.

not, ‘So that ye cannot do the things that ye would,’ as if the flesh overcame the spirit—a translation which hath not only nothing to do with the original text of the Apostle, but likewise makes his whole argument nothing worth, yea, asserts just the reverse of what he is proving.

33. ‘They who are of Christ’,

16

Cf. Gal. 5:24.

who ‘abide in him’,

17

1 John 2:27, 28.

‘have crucified the flesh with its affections and lusts.’

18

Cf. Gal. 5:24.

They abstain from all those works of the flesh: from ‘adultery and fornication’; from ‘uncleanness and lasciviousness’; from ‘idolatry, witchcraft, hatred, variance’; from ‘emulations, wrath, strife, sedition, heresies, envyings, murders, drunkenness, revellings’

19

Gal. 5:19-21.

—from every design, and word, and work to which the corruption of nature leads. Although they feel the root of bitterness

20

Heb. 12:15.

in themselves, yet are they endued with power from on high to trample it continually under foot, so that it cannot ‘spring up to trouble them’:

21

Cf. ibid.

insomuch that every fresh assault which they undergo only gives them fresh occasion of praise, of crying out, ‘Thanks be unto God, who giveth us the victory, through Jesus Christ our Lord.’

22

Cf. 1 Cor. 15:57.

44. They now ‘walk after the Spirit’ both in their hearts and lives. They are taught of him to love God and their neighbour with a love which is as ‘a well of water, springing up into everlasting life’.

23

John 4:14.

And by him they are led into every holy desire, into every divine and heavenly temper, till every thought which arises in their heart is holiness unto the Lord.

24

See Zech. 14:20-21; Jer. 2:3.

55. They who ‘walk after the Spirit’ are also led by him into all holiness of conversation. Their speech is ‘always in grace, seasoned with salt’,

25

Cf. Col. 4:6.

with the love and fear of God. ‘No corrupt communication comes out of their mouth, but (only) that which is good;’ that which is ‘to the use of edifying’, which is ‘meet to 237minister grace to the hearers’.

26

Cf. Eph. 4:29.

And herein likewise do they exercise themselves day and night to do only the things which please God; in all their outward behaviour to follow him who ‘left us an example that we might tread in his steps’;

27

Cf. 1 Pet. 2:21.

in all their intercourse with their neighbour to walk in justice, mercy, and truth; and ‘whatsoever they do’, in every circumstance of life, to ‘do all to the glory of God.’

28

Cf. 1 Cor. 10:31.

66. These are they who indeed ‘walk after the Spirit’. Being filled with faith and with the Holy Ghost, they possess in their hearts, and show forth in their lives, in the whole course of their words and actions, the genuine fruits of the Spirit of God, namely, ‘love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, fidelity, meekness, temperance’,

29

Gal. 5:22-23.

and whatsoever else is lovely or praiseworthy.

30

See Phil. 4:8.

They ‘adorn in all things the gospel of God our Saviour’;

31

Cf. Titus 2:10.

and give full proof to all mankind that they are indeed actuated by the same Spirit ‘which raised up Jesus from the dead’.

32

Cf. Rom. 8:11.

2

1II. 1. I proposed to show, in the second place, how ‘there is no condemnation to them which are’ thus ‘in Christ Jesus’, and thus ‘walk, not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.’

And, first, to believers in Christ walking thus ‘there is no condemnation’ on account of their past sins. God condemneth them not for any of these; they are as though they had never been; they are ‘cast as a stone into the depth of the sea’,

33

Cf. Mic. 7:19.

and he remembereth them no more. God having ‘set forth his Son to be a propitiation for them, through faith in his blood, hath declared unto them his righteousness, for the remission of the sins that are past’.

34

Cf. Rom. 3:25.

He layeth therefore none of these to their charge;

35

See Acts 7:60; Rom. 8:33.

their memorial is perished with them.

36

Ps. 9:6.

22. And there is no condemnation in their own breast, no sense of guilt, or dread of the wrath of God. They ‘have the witness in themselves’;

37

Cf. 1 John 5:10.

they are conscious of their interest in the blood of sprinkling.

38

See Heb. 12:24.

They ‘have not received again the spirit of bondage unto fear’, unto doubt and racking uncertainty; but they ‘have 238received the Spirit of adoption, crying in their hearts, Abba, Father’.

39

Cf. Rom. 8:15.

Thus ‘being justified by faith, they have the peace’

40

Cf. Rom. 5:1.

of God ruling in their hearts, flowing from a continual sense of his pardoning mercy, and ‘the answer of a good conscience toward God’.

41

1 Pet. 3:21.

33. If it be said, ‘But sometimes a believer in Christ may lose his sight of the mercy of God; sometimes such darkness may fall upon him that he no longer sees him that is invisible,

42

See Heb. 11:27.

no longer feels that witness in himself of his part in the atoning blood; and then he is inwardly condemned, he hath again “the sentence of death in himself”.’

43

Cf. 2 Cor. 1:9.

I answer, supposing it so to be, supposing him not to see the mercy of God, then he is not a believer; for faith implies light, the light of God shining upon the soul. So far therefore as anyone loses this light, he for the time loses his faith. And no doubt a true believer in Christ may lose the light of faith. And so far as this is lost he may for a time fall again into condemnation. But this is not the case of them who now ‘are in Christ Jesus’, who now believe in his name. For so long as they believe and walk after the Spirit neither God condemns them nor their own heart.

44

Note the ‘third alternative’ here to the polarities of over-anxious consciences, on the one hand, and to the ‘perseverance of the saints’, on the other. Assurance (‘the light of faith’) is a gift; it may be lost and yet also recovered. It is interesting to see how tenaciously Wesley argued against ‘final perseverance’, as in Predestination Calmly Considered, 72-86, and Nos. 13, On Sin in Believers; 41, Wandering Thoughts; 46, ‘The Wilderness State’; and 47, ‘Heaviness through Manifold Temptations’. See also how skilfully he edits his Puritan authors in A Christian Library, quietly omitting their arguments for it, as in Manton (1620-77), Sermons on Several Subjects, in Vol. 12.

44. They are not condemned, secondly, for any present sins, for now transgressing the commandments of God. For they do not transgress them; they do not ‘walk after the flesh, but after the Spirit’. This is the continual proof of their ‘love of God, that they keep his commandments’:

45

Cf. 1 John 5:3 and Notes.

even as St. John bears witness, ‘Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin. For his seed remaineth in him, and he cannot sin, because he is born of God;’

46

1 John 3:9.

he cannot so long as that seed of God, that loving, holy faith, remaineth in him. So long as ‘he keepeth himself’ herein ‘that wicked one toucheth him not.’

47

1 John 5:18.

Now it is evident he is not condemned for the sins which he doth not commit at all. They 239therefore who are thus ‘led by the Spirit are not under the law’:

Gal. 5:18.

not under the curse or condemnation of it, for it condemns none but those who break it. Thus that law of God, ‘Thou shalt not steal,’

48

Exod. 20:15.

condemns none but those who do steal. Thus, ‘Remember the sabbath day to keep it holy’

49

Exod. 20:8.

condemns those only who do not keep it holy. But ‘against’ the fruits of the Spirit ‘there is no law.’

Ver. 23.

As the Apostle more largely declares in those memorable words of his former Epistle to Timothy, ‘We know that the law is good if a man use it lawfully; knowing this’ (if while he uses the law of God, in order either to convince or direct, he know and remember this), ὅτι δικαίῳ νόμος οὐ κεῖται (not ‘that the law is not made for a righteous man’, but) ‘that the law does not lie against a righteous man’ (it has no force against him, no power to condemn him), ‘but against the lawless and disobedient, against the ungodly and sinners, against the unholy and profane; …according to the glorious gospel of the blessed God.’

1 Tim. 1:8-9, 11. [κεῖται, from κεῖμαι, means ‘to lie’ or ‘to lean’, as Wesley has it here (pace Sugden, I.169 and n.). Its figurative meaning is ‘to be valid’ or ‘relevant’. The clause may thus be translated, ‘The Law has no valid bearing on behaviour at this level…’ (which is Wesley’s point). Cf. Arndt and Gingrich, Greek-English Lexicon, p. 428; see also Wesley’s Notes on this ver.]

55. They are not condemned, thirdly, for inward sin, even though it does now remain. That the corruption of nature does still remain, even in those who are the children of God by faith; that they have in them the seeds of pride and vanity, of anger, lust and evil desire, yea, sin of every kind, is too plain to be denied, being matter of daily experience. And on this account it is that St. Paul, speaking to those whom he had just before witnessed to be ‘in Christ Jesus’,

1 Cor. 1:2.

to have been ‘called of God into the fellowship (or participation) of his Son Jesus Christ’,

Ver. 9.

yet declares, ‘Brethren, I could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal; even as unto babes in Christ.’

1 Cor. 3:1.

‘Babes in Christ’—so we see they were ‘in Christ’; they were believers in a low degree. And yet how much of sin remained in them! Of that ‘carnal mind’ which ‘is not subject to the law of God’!

6 2406. And yet for all this they are not condemned. Although they feel the flesh, the evil nature in them; although they are more sensible day by day that their ‘heart is deceitful, and desperately wicked’;

yet so long as they do not yield thereto, so long as they give no place to the devil, so long as they maintain a continual war with all sin, with pride, anger, desire, so that the flesh hath not dominion over them, but they still ‘walk after the Spirit’: there is ‘no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus’. God is well-pleased with their sincere though imperfect obedience; and they ‘have confidence toward God’, knowing they are his ‘by the Spirit which he hath given them’.

1 John 3:[21], 24.

77. Nay, fourthly, although they are continually convinced of sin cleaving to all they do; although they are conscious of not fulfilling the perfect law, either in their thoughts, or words, or works; although they know they do not love the Lord their God with all their heart, and mind, and soul, and strength; although they feel more or less of pride or self-will stealing in and mixing with their best duties; although even in their more immediate intercourse with God, when they assemble themselves with the great congregation, and when they pour out their souls in secret to him who seeth all the thoughts and intents of the heart, they are continually ashamed of their wandering thoughts,

or of the deadness and dullness of their affections—yet there is no condemnation to them still, either from God or from their own heart. The consideration of these manifold defects only gives them a deeper sense that they have always need of that blood of sprinkling which speaks for them in the ears of God, and that advocate with the Father who ‘ever liveth to make intercession for them.’ So far are these from driving them away from him in whom they have believed, that they rather drive them the closer to him, whom they feel the want of every moment. And at the same time, the deeper sense they have of this want the more earnest 241desire do they feel, and the more diligent they are, as they ‘have received the Lord Jesus, so to walk in him’.

88. They are not condemned, fifthly, for ‘sins of infirmity’, as they are usually called.

(Perhaps it were advisable rather to call them infirmities, that we may not seem to give any countenance to sin, or to extenuate it in any degree by thus coupling it with infirmity.) But if we must retain so ambiguous and dangerous an expression, by ‘sins of infirmity’ I would mean such involuntary failings as the saying a thing we believe true, though in fact it prove to be false; or the hurting our neighbour without knowing or designing it, perhaps when we designed to do him good. Though these are deviations from the holy and acceptable and perfect will of God, yet they are not properly sins, nor do they bring any guilt on the conscience of ‘them which are in Christ Jesus’. They separate not between God and them, neither intercept the light of his countenance, as being no ways inconsistent with their general character of ‘walking not after the flesh, but after the Spirit’.

99. Lastly, ‘there is no condemnation’ to them for anything whatever which it is not in their power to help; whether it be of an inward or outward nature, and whether it be doing something or leaving something undone. For instance, the Lord’s Supper is to be administered, but you do not partake thereof. Why do you not? You are confined by sickness; therefore you cannot help omitting it—and for the same reason you are not condemned. There is no guilt, because there is no choice. As there is ‘a willing mind, it is accepted, according to that a man hath, not according to that he hath not’.

10 24210. A believer indeed may sometimes be grieved because he cannot do what his soul longs for. He may cry out, when he is detained from worshipping God in the great congregation, ‘Like as the hart panteth after the water brooks, so panteth my soul after thee, O God. My soul is athirst for God, yea even for the living God. When shall I come to appear in the presence of God?’

He may earnestly desire (only still saying in his heart, ‘Not as I will, but as thou wilt’) to ‘go again with the multitude, and bring them forth into the house of God’. But still, if he cannot go, he feels no condemnation, no guilt, no sense of God’s displeasure; but can cheerfully yield up those desires with, ‘O my soul, put thy trust in God: for I will yet give him thanks, who is the help of my countenance and my God.’

1111. It is more difficult to determine concerning those which are usually styled ‘sins of surprise’:

as when one who commonly in patience possesses his soul on a sudden and violent temptation speaks or acts in a manner not consistent with the royal law, ‘Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.’ Perhaps it is not easy to fix a general rule concerning transgressions of this nature. We cannot say either that men are, or that they are not, condemned for sins of surprise in general. But it seems whenever a believer is by surprise overtaken in a fault there is more or less condemnation as there is more or less concurrence of his will. In proportion as a sinful desire or word or action is more or less voluntary, so we may conceive God is more or less displeased, and there is more or less guilt upon the soul.

1212. But if so, then there may be some sins of surprise which bring much guilt and condemnation. For in some instances our being surprised is owing to some wilful and culpable neglect; or to a sleepiness of soul which might have been prevented, or shaken off before the temptation came. A man may be previously warned, either of God or man, that trials and danger are at hand, and yet may say in his heart, ‘A little more slumber, a little more 243folding of the hands to rest.’

Now if such an one afterwards fall, though unawares, into the snare which he might have avoided, that he fell unawares is no excuse—he might have foreseen and have shunned the danger. The falling even by surprise, in such an instance as this, is in effect a wilful sin; and as such must expose the sinner to condemnation both from God and his own conscience.

1313. On the other hand, there may be sudden assaults either from the world, or the god of this world, and frequently from our own evil hearts, which we did not, and hardly could foresee. And by these even a believer, while weak in faith, may possibly be borne down, suppose into a degree of anger, or thinking evil of another, with scarce any concurrence of his will. Now in such a case the jealous God would undoubtedly show him that he had done foolishly. He would be convinced of having swerved from the perfect law, from the mind which was in Christ,

and consequently grieved with a godly sorrow, and lovingly ashamed before God. Yet need he not come into condemnation. God layeth not folly to his charge, but hath compassion upon him, even ‘as a father pitieth his own children’. And his heart condemneth him not; in the midst of that sorrow and shame he can still say, ‘I will trust and not be afraid. For the Lord Jehovah is my strength and my song; he is also become my salvation.’

3

1III. 1. It remains only to draw some practical inferences from the preceding considerations.

And, first, if there be ‘no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus’, and ‘walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit’, on account of their past sins; then ‘Why art thou fearful, O thou of little faith?’

71

Cf. Matt. 8:26.

Though thy sins were once more in number than the sand,

72

Ps. 139:18.

what is that to thee now thou art in Christ Jesus? ‘Who shall lay anything to the charge of God’s elect? It is God that justifieth: who is he that condemneth?’

73

Rom. 8:33-34.

All the sins thou hast committed from thy youth up until the hour when thou wast ‘accepted in the Beloved’

74

Eph. 1:6.

are driven away as chaff,

75

See Hos. 13:3.

are gone, are lost, swallowed up, remembered no more. Thou art now ‘born 244of the Spirit’;

76

John 3:6, 8.

wilt thou be troubled or afraid for what was done before thou wert born? Away with thy fears! Thou art not called to fear, but to the ‘spirit of love and of a sound mind’.

77

2 Tim. 1:7.

Know thy calling. Rejoice in God thy Saviour, and give thanks to God thy Father through him.

22. Wilt thou say, ‘But I have again committed sin, since I had redemption through his blood;

78

Eph. 1:7; Col.1:14.

and therefore it is that “I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes”’?

79

Job 42:6.

It is meet thou shouldst abhor thyself; and it is God who hath wrought thee to this selfsame thing. But dost thou now believe? Hath he again enabled thee to say, ‘I know that my Redeemer liveth;’

80

Job 19:25.

‘and the life which I now live, I live by faith in the Son of God’?

81

Cf. Gal. 2:20.

Then that faith again cancels all that is past, and there is no condemnation to thee. At whatsoever time thou truly believest in the name of the Son of God, all thy sins antecedent to that hour vanish away as the morning dew. Now, then, ‘Stand thou fast in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made thee free.’

82

Cf. Gal. 5:1.

He hath once more made thee free from the power of sin, as well as from the guilt and punishment of it. O ‘be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage’!

83

Ibid.

Neither the vile, devilish bondage of sin, of evil desires, evil tempers, or words, or works, the most grievous yoke on this side hell; nor the bondage of slavish tormenting fear, of guilt and self-condemnation.

33. But, secondly, do all they which abide ‘in Christ Jesus walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit’? Then we cannot but infer that whosoever now committeth sin hath no part or lot in this matter. He is even now condemned by his own heart. But ‘if our heart condemn us’,

84

1 John 3:20.

if our own conscience beareth witness that we are guilty, undoubtedly God doth; for he ‘is greater than our heart, and knoweth all things’;

85

Ibid.

so that we cannot deceive him, if we can ourselves. And think not to say, ‘I was justified once; my sins were once forgiven me.’ I know not that; neither will I dispute whether they were or no. Perhaps, at this distance of time, ‘tis next to impossible to know with any tolerable degree of certainty whether that was a true, genuine work of God, or whether thou didst only deceive thy own soul. But this I know with the utmost 245degree of certainty, ‘He that committeth sin is of the devil.’

86

1 John 3 :8. A sharp denial of the notion popularly associated with Calvinism: ‘once in grace, always in grace.’ Here, again, is Wesley’s insistence that only wilful sin forfeits grace. But even wilful sins may be repented and forgiven.

Therefore thou art of thy father the devil. It cannot be denied; for the works of thy father thou dost. O flatter not thyself with vain hopes. Say not to thy soul, ‘Peace, peace!’ For there is no peace.

87

See Jer. 6:14; 8:11.

Cry aloud! Cry unto God out of the deep,

88

See Ps. 130:1 (BCP).

if haply he may hear thy voice. Come unto him as at first, as wretched and poor, as sinful, miserable, blind, and naked. And beware thou suffer thy soul to take no rest till his pardoning love be again revealed, till he ‘heal thy backslidings’,

89

Cf. Jer. 3:22.

and fill thee again with the ‘faith that worketh by love’.

90

Cf. Gal. 5:6; cf. also, No. 2, The Almost Christian, II.6 and n.

44. Thirdly, is there no condemnation to them which ‘walk after the Spirit’ by reason of inward sin still remaining, so long as they do not give way thereto; nor by reason of sin cleaving to all they do? Then fret not thyself because of ungodliness, though it still remain in thy heart.

91

Notice Wesley’s version here of Luther’s simul justus et peccator and his different nuancing of it. See above, II.6; and No. 13, On Sin in Believers, intro., III.1-9 and n.

Repine not because thou still comest short of the glorious image of God; nor yet because pride, self-will, or unbelief, cleave to all thy words and works. And be not afraid to know all the evil of thy heart, to know thyself as also thou art known.

92

See 1 Cor. 13:12.

Yea, desire of God that thou mayst not think of thyself more highly than thou oughtest to think.

93

See Rom. 12:3.

Let thy continual prayer be:

Show me, as my soul can bear,

The depth of inbred sin:

All the unbelief declare,

The pride that lurks within!

94

Charles Wesley, ‘Waiting for Christ the Prophet’, st. 5, in Hymns and Sacred Poems (1742), p. 209 (Poet. Wks., II.263).

But when he heareth thy prayer, and unveils thy heart, when he shows thee throughly what spirit thou art of; then beware that thy faith fail thee not, that thou suffer not thy shield to be torn from thee. Be abased. Be humbled in the dust. See thyself 246nothing, less than nothing, and vanity.

95

Cf. Isa. 40:17.

But still, ‘let not thy heart be troubled, neither let it be afraid.’

96

Cf. John 14:27.

Still hold fast, ‘I’, even I, ‘have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.’

97

1 John 2:1.

And ‘as the heavens are higher than the earth, so is his love higher than even my sins.’

98

Cf. Ps. 103:11.

Therefore God is merciful to thee a sinner!

99

See Luke 18:13.

Such a sinner as thou art! God is love; and Christ hath died. Therefore the Father himself loveth thee. Thou art his child. Therefore he will withhold from thee no manner of thing that is good.

100

Matt. 7:11.

Is it good that the whole body of sin which is now crucified in thee should be destroyed? It shall be done. Thou shalt be ‘cleansed from all filthiness both of flesh and spirit’.

101

Cf. 2 Cor. 7:1.

Is it good that nothing should remain in thy heart but the pure love of God alone? Be of good cheer! ‘Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart and mind and soul and strength.’

102

Mark 12:30; Luke 10:27.

‘Faithful is he that hath promised, who also will do it.’

103

Cf. Heb. 10:23.

It is thy part patiently to continue in the work of faith, and in the labour of love; and in cheerful peace, in humble confidence, with calm, and resigned, and yet earnest expectation to wait till ‘the zeal of the Lord of Hosts shall perform this’.

104

Cf. Isa. 9:7; note this whole paragraph as a comment on the meaning of a believer’s assurance, despite the remains of sin in believers (for which, see No. 13). It is equally an exhortation to the constant repentance of believers (for which, see No. 14).

55. Fourthly, if they that ‘are in Christ and walk after the Spirit’ are not condemned for sins of infirmity, as neither for involuntary failings, nor for anything whatever which they are not able to help; then beware, O thou that hast faith in his blood, that Satan herein ‘gain no advantage over thee’.

105

Cf. 2 Cor. 2:11.

Thou art still foolish and weak, blind and ignorant; more weak than any words can express, more foolish than it can yet enter into thy heart to conceive, knowing nothing yet as thou oughtest to know. Yet let not all thy weakness and folly, or any fruit thereof which thou art not yet able to avoid, shake thy faith, thy filial trust in God, or disturb thy peace or joy in the Lord. The rule which some give as to wilful sins, and which in that case may perhaps be dangerous, is undoubtedly wise and safe if it be applied only to the case of weakness and infirmities.

106

An echo of Law’s stress on God’s mercifulness toward all Christians who hold to their trust in Christ’s sufficient merit and grace: ‘Weak and imperfect men shall, notwithstanding their frailties and defects, be received as having pleased God, if they have done their utmost to please him…. We cannot offer to God the service of angels [or of] man in a state of perfection; but fallen men can do their best, and this is the perfection that is required of us’ (Serious Call, Works, IV.23-24).

Art 247thou fallen, O man of God?

107

See Isa. 14:12.

Yet do not lie there, fretting thyself and bemoaning thy weakness; but meekly say, ‘Lord, I shall fall thus every moment unless thou uphold me with thy hand.’ And then, arise! Leap and walk. Go on thy way. ‘Run with patience the race set before thee.’

108

Cf. Heb. 12:1.

66. Lastly, since a believer need not come into condemnation, even though he be surprised into what his soul abhors (suppose his being surprised is not owing to any carelessness or wilful neglect of his own); if thou who believest art thus overtaken in a fault, then grieve unto the Lord: it shall be a precious balm. Pour out thy heart before him,

109

See Ps. 62:8.

and show him of thy trouble. And pray with all thy might to him who is ‘touched with the feeling of thy infirmities’

110

Cf. Heb.4:15.

that he would stablish and strengthen and settle

111

See 1 Pet. 5:10.

thy soul, and suffer thee to fall no more. But still he condemneth thee not. Wherefore shouldst thou fear? Thou hast no need of any ‘fear that hath torment’.

112

Cf. 1 John 4:18.

Thou shalt love him that loveth thee, and it sufficeth: more love will bring more strength. And as soon as thou lovest him with all thy heart thou shall be ‘perfect and entire, lacking nothing’.

113

Cf. Jas. 1:4.

Wait in peace for that hour when ‘the God of peace shall sanctify thee wholly, so that thy whole spirit and soul and body may be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ’!

114

1 Thess. 5:23.