Notes:
Sermon 142: The Wisdom of Winning Souls
1This sermon mas originally designed for a service of ordination in Christ Church Cathedral on September 19, 1731, which explains its opening reference to ‘a place where philosophy or the love of wisdom is so universally professed and so carefully cultivated’. It was a gracious phrase from a Christ Church alumnus, by then mildly notorious as the leader of the group labelled ‘the Godly Club’.
2The sermon’s basic theme is the evangelical power of holy living: ‘this is inseparably connected with the winning of souls.’ The motive and end of authentic evangelism is ‘the glory of God’, an idea which is developed rather elaborately. The correlation between ‘holiness and happiness’ that will bulk so large in the later Wesley is also affirmed here; it is crucial in ‘the winning of souls’ to make religion appear as winsome as it really is.
3The first step in ‘winning souls’ is bringing the seeker both to a conscious desire for the purification of his heart from ‘its darling lusts’ and to the deliberate ‘regulating of the affections’. This must then be followed by a positive commitment to holy living as a gift and a task. The final step in the transaction is a ‘fixing’ of the convert in his new-found ‘generous resolutions’. None of this is possible, of course, by human resolution alone; it is all the work of grace.
4What would have been most challenging in this sermon to its Christ Church auditory is its generous allowances for irregular ministries and even for lay ministries of evangelism (note the closing section entitled, ‘Inferences’). This is an interesting affirmation of the evangelical mission of all Christian believers; it is also a denial of any exclusive right of the ordained clergy to evangelize. Here, then, at a very early stage, is Wesley’s distinction between the duty of all Christians to bear witness to their Christian faith (and to win others to it) and the special rights of ordination to the sacramental ministries of the church (see No. 121, ‘Prophets and Priests’). When, therefore, Wesley came later to employ laymen as his assistants in the Methodist Revival, he already had a theory for it to buttress his mother’s practical wisdom.
See Moore, Wesley, I.505-6, for Susanna’s comments about Thomas Maxfield, Wesley’s first full-time lay assistant.
504:306John Wesley’s copy of this sermon has not survived; what we have is a manuscript in Charles Wesley’s hand, in a volume bearing the note, ‘transcribed from my brother’s copies ’. It is in the Colman Collection in the Methodist Archives, Manchester. That transcription is given a title, as above, in Charles’s hand, and begins with an abbreviated invocation (I.N.D.—In nomine Dei). There is also a marginal notation, in another hand, ‘Preached before the University of Oxford’. Further annotations, compared with John Wesley’s diary, indicate that it was also preached in St. Miles, Oxford (September 26, 1731), and in St. Mary’s, Gloucester (July 9, 1732). John’s diary also shows that it was composed during the week of July 5-12, 1731, well in advance of its first preaching. His sermon list indicates that this was his fifty-fourth written sermon;
Heitzenrater, ‘John Wesley’s Early Sermons’, p. 121.
Proverbs 11:30
I.N.D.
In Nomine Dei; see No. 139, ‘On the Sabbath’, n. 1.
In the eleventh chapter of the Proverbs, at the thirtieth verse, it is written,
He that winneth souls is wise.
1In a place where philosophy or the love of wisdom is so universally professed and so carefully cultivated, where so many are obliged by their office to study and practise this particular sort of wisdom, and where more are designed and endeavouring to qualify themselves for the same holy function, it can’t but be highly proper to make that wisdom the subject of our consideration, which a great part of us are engaged by so peculiar 04:307ties to recommend both by our lives and doctrines;
The majority of Wesley’s audience would have been ordained priests; cf. BCP, Ordering of Priests, opening and closing collects.
2He that winneth souls, that draws them from vice to virtue, from rebellion against God to obedience, that recovers them from darkness and the shadow of death to the way of light and peace, that disentangles them from that fatal snare from which they had no hope, nay, no desire, of escaping, that disappoints the lion of his prey, even when he had said, there is none to help them—he is wise indeed! As will be evident if we consider:
3First, the end he proposes, and secondly, the means that lead to it.
10I. First, the end he proposes. Winning of souls may be considered, first, as bringing glory to God. ’Tis true, no action of any created being can do this in a strict sense, can at all add to that essential glory wherewith his Creator was clothed from eternity. Yet in a lower sense, whatsoever we do may be done to the glory of God; that is, may at least remotely tend to manifest his glory, to increase the honour paid to him by his creatures, to make him more known and more loved.
1And in this sense he that winneth souls eminently advances the glory of God, by displaying his glorious nature and attributes to the sons of men, who alone of all the visible creation are capable of contemplating them. Man alone of all the inhabitants of this world can acknowledge and praise him that made it; can raise his thoughts and affections from sensible objects to him ‘whom no man hath seen nor can see’.
1 Tim. 6:16.
2It was for this very thing that God wrought those works, that ‘his eternal power and Godhead’
Rom. 1:20.
Cf. Ps. 148:5 (BCP).
Cf. Gen. 2:1.
Cf. Heb. 1:3.
Cf. Gen. 22:12, 16.
See Rom. 8:32.
3This purpose it is which God hath uniformly pursued through our creation, preservation, and redemption.
See BCP, Thanksgivings, A General Thanksgiving.
4Now this is of two sorts: deliverance from misery, and advancement to happiness. Of the former we need only observe this one circumstance, that it is eternal (as indeed it must be, unless there were repentance in the grave, since endless sin implies endless misery).
See No. 124, ‘Human Life a Dream’, §13.
See Nos. 67, ‘On Divine Providence’, §13; and 54, ‘On Eternity’.
5The same single consideration is enough to give us a general notion of that happiness, the enjoyment of which is secured to him who is rescued from endless misery. That this too is eternal we know, and so need not inquire into the particulars. Nor indeed can we tell these if we would. If it were possible for man to utter them, St. Paul doubtless, after having been in the third heaven,
2 Cor. 12:2.
See Rev. 21:4.
See Ps. 36:8.
See Ps. 107:9 (BCP).
Cf. Heb. 12:23-24.
6Here is wisdom! The pursuing such an end as this! The recovering him that was just sinking into the gulf of misery to happiness incomprehensible, eternal! To the depth of the mercies of God! This is the good which he that wins a soul brings to him whom he wins to virtue, over and above the good he brings to himself—which is thirdly to be considered.
7And no small part of the good it brings to himself is the honour that necessarily attends it, the honour of answering the end of his creation, promoting at once the glory of God and the good of man; of sharing in the office of those superior natures who continually minister to the heirs of salvation; of working together with God, of being a fellow-labourer with the ever blessed Spirit, and Jesus Christ the righteous!
1 John 2:1; a nod to those (in that audience and elsewhere) who did, indeed, count Wesley’s zeal as ‘madness’; cf. No. 150, ‘Hypocrisy in Oxford’ [English], II.14 and n.
See 1 Cor. 1:20-25.
1 Sam. 2:30.
8Nor can it ever be said of this honour, as is too often true of the honour of men, that it brings no advantage with it. This is never the case with regard to the honour which cometh from God. 04:310None can be conscious of this without an immediate advantage, without such satisfaction as words cannot express. None can resemble God in extending his mercy even to the evil and unjust, without experiencing, even at that time, some degree of his happiness whose goodness he imitates. No human creature can have so little of the law of kindness written in his heart as not to feel his heart burn within him
See Luke 24:32; this biblical metaphor of the warmed heart was common in the devotional literature of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and would be brought even more vividly to Wesley’s attention in 1738 in the ‘heart theology’ of the Moravians.
See Jas. 5:20.
9A foretaste this of that more ample reward which shall hereafter enlarge his heart, when he, with those whom he hath been a means of saving, shall together enter into the joy of their Lord. We need not dispute whether St. James touches upon this reward in those remarkable words, ‘Brethren, if any of you do err from the truth, and one convert him, let him know that he which converteth a sinner from the error of his way shall save a soul from death, and hide a multitude of sins.’
Jas. 5:19-20.
See Luke 15:7.
See Ezek. 18:22.
See Col. 2:14.
See Rev. 21:27.
10Neither need we inquire what foundation there is for that opinion of the ancients,
Cf. Origen, Exhortation to Martyrdom (A.D. 235), II.14-16, 30, 47-51; see also J. L. von Mosheim, Institutiones historiae ecclesiasticae (1726; Eng. tr. by J. Murdock, 1841), ‘Century’ I, v.9-15. For a review of the history and theology of martyrdom in the early church, see W. H. C. Frend, Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church (1963), pp. 199-200, 353-58.
Cf. 1 Cor. 15:41-42.
1 Cor. 3:8 [note the echo here of ‘the gospel of moral rectitude’].
Cf. Dan. 12:3.
11Such is the wisdom of him that winneth souls! Such is the end which he proposes! The means which lead to that end I come now, under my second general head, to consider.
20II. The first of these is, the regulating his understanding [of him] whom he endeavours to win to virtue; the freeing him from those confused apprehensions of things, those false judgments and ill-grounded conclusions which he has long been planting in himself, and which perhaps have been striking root for many years. Whether the first seeds of these were early sown by education, or afterwards by ill advice or example; whether they relate to faith or practice in general, or to any particular branch of either; whether they are errors of a whole sect of men, or peculiar to the person infected—they are carefully to be weeded out, and no root of bitterness left.
Heb. 12:15; note the theory of evangelism by Christian nurture that is here presupposed by the early Wesley.
1In particular there is an absolute necessity of removing the confused notion which most vicious men entertain of virtue. They apprehend religion as ‘a terrible spectre looking down from heaven only to enslave the earth, standing over them with so horrible an aspect’
A curious conflation (in translation) of Virgil, Aeneid, iii.658 (monstrum horrendum, informe, ingens), and Lucretius, De Rerum Natura (On the Nature of Things), i.65 (horribili super aspectu mortalibus instans). See No. 151, ‘Hypocrisy in Oxford’ [Latin], I.9; and An Earnest Appeal, §65 (11:72 in this edn.).
Eccles. 7:16; a text favoured by the latitudinarians against all rigorists and enthusiasts. Later (1739), a mild-mannered Tory poet, Dr. Joseph Trapp, ally of Samuel Wesley, Sen., in the Sacheverell affair, would gain fame and opprobrium from George Whitefield’s denunciations of his sermon in Christ Church, Newgate, on The Nature, Folly, Sin and Danger of Being Righteous Overmuch.
2To make one who thinks thus wise unto salvation, he must be rescued from all these errors. And that the confused notion he has of religion, the ground of them all, may be cleared, he must be brought to fix his eye upon her, that he may perceive ‘he feared where no fear was’;
Cf. Ps. 53:6 (BCP).
See Ps. 85:11 (BCP).
Cf. Prov. 3:17.
Another early version of Wesley’s eudaemonism; see No. 5, ‘Justification by Faith’, I.4 and n. See also No. 84, The Important Question, III.12, where Wesley speaks of the man who ‘sold his soul for threescore years of pleasure’.
Ps. 111:10 (BCP).
3But the convincing an ill man
I.e., ‘wicked’ or ‘depraved’; cf. OED, 3.
Cf. Judg. 16:9.
4Indeed without doing this the other can’t be done throughly—he that would well enlighten the head must cleanse the heart. Otherwise the disorder of the will again disorders the understanding, and perverseness of affection will again cause an equal perverseness of judgment. For whatever inclination is contrary to reason is likewise destructive of it; and whoever makes the world his god, that god will surely blind his eyes.
See 2 Cor. 4:4.
5This then is the most important work of all, namely, ‘the laying the axe to the root of the tree’;
Cf. Matt. 3:10.
A cliché to match ‘bosom sin’, etc.; cf. No. 48, ‘Self-denial’, II.2 and n.
Cf. Eph. 2:12.
6When he has determined to renounce these inclinations which are evil in themselves, the next point is to bring him to a resolution of transferring those which are not so to new objects, of ‘setting these affections on things above, and not on things of the earth’.
Cf. Col. 3:2.
See 2 Cor. 4:18.
Blaise Pascal, Pensées, H. F. Stewart, ed. (London, Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1950), pp. 304-5; cf. No. 30, ‘Sermon on the Mount, X’, §7 and n. For the phrase ‘half-Christians’, see Nos. 2, The Almost Christian, proem and n.; and 4, Scriptural Christianity, II.5 and n.
7After inspiring a sinner with this generous resolution, one step more is to be taken, and that is to fix him in it, to guard him from a relapse, lest his last state should be worse than the first;
See Matt. 12:45.
Cf. Ps. 17:5.
Cf. Eph. 6:11-13.
A later hand has added ‘truly’ before ‘wise’.
8Inf[erences]. But is not this a higher degree of wisdom than anyone who was born of a woman hath yet attained to? This is the inference which a man of reflection would immediately draw from what has been said of it. ‘Who is sufficient for these things?’
2 Cor. 2:16.
See Matt. 5:29-30.
See Col. 3:2.
Matt. 19:26.
9But with God all things are possible!
Ibid.
A distorted echo from 1 Kgs. 22:15.
Cf. Phil 4:13.
See 2 Cor. 12:9.
See Deut. 33:25.
See Gal. 6:9.
10I would not here be understood to exclude all but these from having any share in this glorious work. No! God forbid! How shall I curse whom God hath not cursed,
Num. 23:8.
See Jas. 5:20.
Luke 11:23.
11Several acts of our blessed office indeed there are which may not be performed unless by particularly commissioned officers; but here a general commission is given to all the servants of Christ to tread in his steps, to do what in them lies
An early reference to the ancient monastic tradition of in se est; see Introduction (1:72 and n. 19, in this edn.); and see Nos. 143, ‘Public Diversions Denounced’, V and n. 48; and 151, ‘Hypocrisy in Oxford’ [Latin], II.7 and n.
12Indeed, if Solomon had only said, ‘The priest that winneth souls is wise,’ they had some colour for saying to all who are not invested with this office, ‘Ye have neither part nor lot in this wisdom;
Cf. Acts 8:21.
Cf. Heb. 13:16.
For further theoretical developments of this doctrine of the place of the ‘extraordinary ministry’ of lay evangelists, see No. 110, Free Grace, §10 and n.; see also No. 121, ‘Prophets and Priests’, for an extended discussion of the distinction between lay preaching (licit) and the lay administration of the sacraments (illicit).
13But is this a time for making restrictions? For binding the hands of any of our fellow-labourers? When the avowed opposers and blasphemers of our holy religion are so zealously labouring to destroy souls; when those who have themselves made shipwreck of the faith
See 1 Tim. 1:19.
Cf. Acts 20:30.
Cf. 2 Pet. 2:1.
Cf. 2 Kgs. 9:32.
See Ps. 94:16.
Ps. 106:23 (BCP).
See Matt. 7:15.
See 1 Pet. 5:8.
See Matt. 19:14.
Num. 16:7.
Luke 16:8; note the absence of an ascription here, in a setting where it would certainly have been expected; see No. 1, Salvation by Faith, III.9 and n. Apparently the ending of John’s sermon was not transcribed; there are two blank pages in the notebook before the next sermon begins.
How to Cite This Entry
Bibliography:
, “.” In , edited by . , 2024. Entry published February 25, 2024. https://wesleyworks.ecdsdev.org/sermons/Sermon142.About this Entry
Entry Title: Sermon 142: The Wisdom of Winning Souls